NEW FAYETTEVILLE OFFICE ADDRESS

200 Dick Street, Suite A, Fayetteville, NC 28301

Learn More

New Clients Email

info@carolinalaw.com

Can I Sue for Identity Theft?

Key Takeaways

  • Identity theft can upend a victim's life in many ways.
  • You can sue for identity theft, but the path is not always clear.
  • An experienced identity theft lawyer can guide you through your case and hold the right parties accountable.

In This Article

Identity theft has become a widespread issue, impacting millions of Americans each year. Its effects often extend beyond the initial fraud, leading to unauthorized charges, debt, damaged credit, and other serious consequences. Recovering from identity theft is often a complex, time-consuming process that takes time to get your life back on track. Part of that recovery process can include recovering compensation through a lawsuit. This guide explains the various causes and consequences of identity theft and how a consumer can sue those responsible. If you were a victim of identity theft, schedule a free consultation with us today.

What Is Considered Identity Theft?

Identity theft occurs when a person or group uses an individual’s personal information without permission. A thief may steal your name, address, Social Security number, financial information, and other private details. With your identity, a criminal can do serious damage to your life. Financial loss is by far the most common consequence of identity theft. According to the Identity Theft Resource Center, in 2025 alone, more than 500,000 people reported a hijacked financial account or an unauthorized new line of credit opened in their name. But identity theft can also affect a person’s criminal, medical, and housing records.

How Identity Theft Happens

Your personally identifiable information can be exposed in many ways. In the past, identity theft relied on pickpocketing or stolen paper records. Today, criminals can use a number of sophisticated methods to steal your identity. Common examples include:

  • Imposter Scams: A type of social engineering scam in which the criminal poses as a bank, government agency, or other legitimate organization to gain access to accounts and personal information.
  • Data Breaches: A 2025 study by the Identity Theft Resource Center identified 3,322 data breaches affecting more than 278 million people. These breaches can expose personal information on the dark web.
  • Phishing: This method of identity theft is increasingly recognized by the general public. Yet, as awareness grows, criminals invent new tactics to infiltrate your life. A phishing attack typically appears as an urgent, unsolicited email, text, or call that pressures you to share personal details while posing as an official organization.
  • Malware: These attacks often rely on phishing to embed a virus within an email or text link. After the user clicks, they may be unaware that their keystrokes are being monitored and the information sent to a hacker.

Identity Theft Warning Signs

Identity theft can have severe consequences for victims who may not even know their personal information was stolen. A thief can sometimes operate under the radar for months before a consumer realizes what happened. Checking your credit report can help you easily identify unusual activity throughout your life. However, there are other signs of identity theft. These include:

  • Credit and loan application denials
  • Housing application denials due to a failed background check
  • Debt collection calls from a line of credit you didn’t open
  • No longer receiving bills
  • Receiving bills for things you did not purchase

Preventing Identity Theft

Using strong passwords and steering clear of common identity theft tactics are just one aspect of protecting yourself. For instance, if a data breach occurs, your information could be exposed without your fault, leaving you feeling helpless. The most effective way to prevent active identity theft from ripping through your life is to check your consumer reports and billing statements regularly. Familiarize yourself with your credit reports from the three main bureaus (Equifax, TransUnion, and Experian) so you can quickly spot any irregularities.

💡Did you know?

The Fair Credit Reporting Act guarantees your right to 3 free credit reports annually. Since the pandemic, that has been upgraded to 3 free reports each week. Learn how to get your reports here.

Consequences of Identity Theft

Identity theft can upend your life in several ways. Most often, criminals who open accounts in victims’ names or drain existing accounts impose an obvious financial burden. Identity theft can cost victims thousands to millions of dollars. It can also damage consumers’ creditworthiness. Overdue accounts and multiple accounts opened at once will take a toll on your credit score. When you go to buy a home or apply for an auto loan, you may be denied through no fault of your own. Victims may also report losing job opportunities due to inaccurate criminal records or insurance denials based on a criminal’s history of using your identity. Because the consequences of identity theft can feel insurmountable, contacting a consumer attorney right away can provide crucial support throughout the rebuilding process.

Who You Can Sue for Identity Theft

Unfortunately, identity thieves are rarely identified or prosecuted. Cyber-criminals can use the dark web to mask their true location. If the crime is not financial (for example, the identity is used for medical purposes), it can be even more difficult to track the perpetrators. Identity theft victims have recourse to sue other parties who contributed to the theft:

  • Financial Institutions: A bank or other financial institution that dispenses funds to a thief or allows someone to open a new account in your name may be held responsible.
  • Credit Reporting Agencies: If a consumer report contains inaccurate records, such as debts or criminal charges, the bureaus are responsible for removing them. Often, it’s difficult for victims of identity theft to get these records properly removed. Failure to remove incorrect information can be a violation of your Fair Credit Reporting Act rights.
  • Other Businesses: There are many businesses that you entrust with your personal information. If an organization is responsible for the theft or fraudulent use of your identity, you may be able to sue for damages. For example, if your losses were the result of a data breach.

How to Sue For Identity Theft

If you are the victim of identity theft, you have legal options beyond simply reporting the crime to the police. The most effective way to make sure you can sue the appropriate parties for your identity theft is to contact a dedicated attorney right away. If the harm incurred is a damaged credit report, your steps may look like this:

  • Record all fraudulent accounts, charges, or transactions associated with your name.
  • Submit official complaints to the Federal Trade Commission and your local police.
  • Contest the fraudulent activities with each creditor, credit bureau, and financial institution involved, preferably via certified mail to maintain a clear record of your efforts.
  • If the credit reporting agency rejects your dispute, consult an identity theft lawyer to begin to sue for damages.

Compensation (Damages) for Identity Theft

The overwhelming consequences of identity theft can strain your life. Fortunately, consumer law provides you with the right to pursue compensation for difficulties you face as a result. Depending on the particular facts of your case, you may have the ability to recover:

  • Compensatory damages for out-of-pocket losses you incurred.
  • Emotional damages for the extreme distress you suffered.
  • Attorney’s fees and costs.
  • Statutory damages for consumer reporting errors ($500-$1,000 per violation).

Why Hire A Lawyer to Sue for Identity Theft

Hiring an identity theft lawyer to sue for damages can help you shoulder the burden of the crime. Your life has been upended enough without the added stress of constant back-and-forth with consumer reporting agencies and businesses. Our highly skilled consumer protection lawyers have proven experience recovering compensation for clients. They use a combination of state and federal regulations to uncover who is responsible and how they can be held accountable.

Contact Us

Identity theft can take a tremendous toll on your life. To get your life back on track, you can sue those responsible. Maginnis Howard represents affected consumers on a contingency basis. That means there is no cost to sign up, and we only get paid if we recover compensation on your behalf. Our attorneys represent consumers on a contingency basis, meaning you don’t pay anything unless we recover compensation on your behalf. Reach out to us for a free consultation to get started with your claim. We have conveniently located offices in Raleigh, Fayetteville, and Charlotte. Call us at (919) 526-0450, visit our contact page, or submit an inquiry via our Live Chat. 

Contact Us

Recent Posts